Welcome to Wishing Well
Wishing Well, located at 2709 E Newberry St in Appleton, WI, is a hidden gem that draws diners in with its welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings. Known for its broasted chicken and popular fish fry, the eatery delights guests with fresh, hearty dishes at great prices. Reviews highlight the friendly service, especially from bartenders like Kara, and the enjoyable ambiance, making it a perfect spot for a casual night out. With enticing specials and happy hour deals, Wishing Well is an ideal destination for both local diners and visitors seeking a satisfying meal and a memorable experience.
Wishing Well: Reviews & Ratings
Cold beer, great fish and shrimp, great price! Go early on Fridays to avoid a wait
I stoped by on a Thursday for lunch. I had their broasted chicken dinner special. It was absolutely fantastic and don't forget to ask for the homemade coleslaw!
Fish Fry was great,ppl an staff friendly Highly recommend
This was a great place! Kara was truly "the friendliest bartender." The food was really good. The atmosphere was nice and the karaoke was great!
It's a quaint bar with solid food and great specials, along with good happy hour deals, It's not great for late-night adventures, but it's a great, off-the-map place to get fed for the night ahead!
I been here a couple of times now, and it's a really fun place to hang out! I have not tried the food yet, but I will soon. Bartenders are very friendly. They even have a back room if you need more space. This bar is not very big however the crowd is very good.
Pool table, dart board, pull tabs, machines, patio, karaoke, happy hour, food service from 11am-9pm and more! Closed on Mondays and most holidays. Taco Tuesdays! Huge, american fully-loaded beef tacos/taco salads/nachos! Wednesday burger specials! Thursday 11am-2pm broasted chicken. From 6pm-9pm broasted (traditional) chicken wings on special! Fish Fry Friday! (FYI - This location has a smaller kitchen so in order to get food out fast and efficient they turn off the grill to use for prep, so just fish and deep fried food on Friday!) Every 3rd Saturday of the month is KARAOKE NIGHT! Sunday broasted chicken dinner! *Sundays close at 8pm* Table service depending on availability! Be mindful, there's usually only one or two bartenders! Also, if its busy, the phones will be tended to LAST. But food does come out fast, so even if the parking lot looks crazy, you can still stop in and get your food (even to go) quickly!
Service was good even though they were busy. Seafood plate is a very generous portion. Good Friday fish fry.
Location
-
2709 E Newberry St, Appleton, WI 54915, United States Hotline: +1 920-734-4472
Welcome to Wishing Well, a charming eatery located in the heart of Appleton, Wisconsin, at 2709 E Newberry St. If you’re searching for a spot that marries a cozy atmosphere with delicious food, you’ve found your destination. Known for its welcoming ambiance and friendly staff, Wishing Well has become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
The essence of Wishing Well lies in its diverse menu. Customers rave about the fresh, quality ingredients, especially their fish and shrimp dishes, which are often described as fantastic. Bailey Lawless notes the “cold beer” that perfectly complements the meal, emphasizing the establishment's commitment to value—a recurring theme echoed in many reviews. Whether you arrive early on a Friday to beat the crowd or stop in for a satisfying lunch during the week, you're in for a treat.
One standout dish that has captured the interest of many diners is the broasted chicken dinner special. According to Mike Bruening, this particular dish is a must-try, and he urges patrons to also indulge in the homemade coleslaw. The fusion of flavors and textures is nothing short of delightful, making it a highlight on the menu.
Fish fry aficionados will find a special place in their hearts for Wishing Well, as highlighted by Renee Reichl. The delicious fish fry paired with the warmth of the staff creates an experience that feels both homely and inviting. It’s a combination that leaves a lasting impression and adds to the community spirit that radiates from this quaint spot.
As you savor the delectable food, you might also enjoy the vibrant atmosphere. With live karaoke and a friendly bartender—like Kara, who was described as "the friendliest bartender"—Wishing Well promises a fun evening that goes beyond just dining. According to Glenn Sokol, it’s a place where solid food and a lively spirit come together seamlessly.
For those seeking a hidden gem that offers fantastic food, great happy hour deals, and a laid-back vibe, Wishing Well should be at the top of your list. As Derek Selle wisely notes, while it's not the place for late-night adventures, it certainly sets the stage for a delightful meal and good company to kickstart your evening plans.
To sum it up, Wishing Well is more than just a restaurant; it's a community cornerstone that embodies the warmth and flavor of Appleton. So next time you're in the area, make a wish and drop by—your taste buds will thank you!